| Amberjack (YW2) | 46 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | This meaty fish has a lot of fans. Most of them are chefs. |
| Anglerfish (YW2) | 40 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | This reclusive deep-sea dweller has its own personal lantern! |
| Barracuda (YW2) | 15 | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | It may look aggressive, but that's just its prominent lower jawline. |
| Beakfish (YW2) | 58 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | A zebra-striped beakfish. The pattern captivates fishermen. |
| Beltfish (YW2) | 33 | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | Ever notice that its long, silvery body glitters and glows? |
| Black Bass (YW2) | 9 | It's most likely somewhere in a pond in Mount Wildwood. | It's only called a black bass because of its color as a fry. |
| Blackfish (YW2) | 20 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | This fish's tender white meat has graced many a sandwich. |
| Carp (YW2) | 1 | It's most likely somewhere in a river in Harrisville. | A common carp. Did you know they're ancestors of goldfish? |
| Catfish (YW2) | 18 | It's most likely somewhere in a pond in Mount Wildwood. | A catfish with a mustache and a weird mouth. Does not meow! |
| Cherry Salmon (YW2) | 37 | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Uptown Springdale. | This river-dwelling fish has distinctive polka-dotted skin. |
| Chub Mackerel (YW2) | 12 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | You can find this fish in the water and in all sorts of tasty dishes! |
| Conger Eel (YW2) | 16 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | This slithery creature loves to explore gooey mud flats. Yuck! |
| Crab (YW2) | 14 | It's most likely somewhere in a river in Harrisville. | This petite crab is commonly found in a river or a pond. |
| Crayfish (YW2) | 2 | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Mount Wildwood. | With fearsome claws and tough armor, crayfish are real fighters. |
| Cuttlefish (YW2) | 27 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | With such changing colors, it's more like a chameleon of the sea. |
| Eel (YW2) | 28 | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Shopper's Row. | It's almost impossible to hold on to this slippery customer. |
| Filefish (YW2) | 39 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | It's a meat eater with a tiny mouth but impressively tough teeth. |
| Firefly Squid (YW2) | 5 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | It makes the night sea sparkle with its glowing body. |
| Flounder (YW2) | 22 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | That's no halibut! Look—its eyes are on the left. That's wrong! |
| Flying Fish (YW2) | 31 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | These wings aren't just for show. This fish can leap out of the water. |
| Giant Huchen (YW2) | 41 | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Uptown Springdale. | An elusive legendary fish said to grow almost six feet long. |
| Grunt (YW2) | 16 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | It's a pretty, striped fish that can lay up to a million eggs. Wow. |
| Halibut (YW2) | 35 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | There's something off about this flounder... Wait—it's a halibut! |
| Jellyfish (YW2) | 6 | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | It's pretty, but you can't eat it... Why'd you catch it? |
| Koi (YW2) | 11 | It's most likely somewhere in Gourd Pond in Breezy Hills. | A big eater. Those tough teeth can even break open seashells. |
| Loach (YW2) | 22 | It's most likely somewhere in a pond in Mount Wildwood. | This fish uses its distinctive and stylish whiskers to hunt for food. |
| Lobster (YW2) | 43 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | Under that spiny exterior, this crustacean is a real delicacy. |
| Mackerel (YW2) | 18 | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | Good broiled, good fried... Everybody likes mackerel. |
| Marlin (YW2) | 70 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | A big ocean fish with a pointy nose. A sport fisher's dream. |
| Mullet (YW2) | 23 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | This large leaping fish is often found jumping around an estuary. |
| Octopus (YW2) | 13 | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | An ink-spewing, eight-tentacled celebrity of the sea. |
| Porcupine Fish (YW2) | 9 | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | It may look lovable, but those spines sure aren't! |
| Porgy (YW2) | 49 | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | Also known as a sea bream, it's famous for that dark coloring. |
| Red Snapper (YW2) | 26 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | I'll take the red one...and make it snappy! |
| Reef Squid (YW2) | 19 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | A very sizable squid with a thin, translucent body. |
| Rockfish (YW2) | 12 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | People can't agree on a name, but they agree it's delicious. |
| Salmon (YW2) | 29 | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Uptown Springdale. | This fish travels all the way back to its birthplace to lay its eggs! |
| Sardine (YW2) | 7 | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | This fish may look like a rose, but it sure doesn't smell like one. |
| Sea Bass (YW2) | 25 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | This robust fish is caught for sport and enjoyed for dinner. |
| Sea Horse (YW2) | 17 | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | Nothing else in the sea looks quite like this little fellow. |
| Shrimp (YW2) | 30 | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | Don't mistake this creature for a prawn... It's a touchy subject. |
| Snakehead (YW2) | 21 | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Blossom Heights. | A violent fish that lives up to its name. Don't get bitten! |
| Softshell Turtle (YW2) | 8 | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Mount Wildwood. | Don't let one of these bite you—it might never let go! |
| Spear Squid (YW2) | 32 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | Its head resembles the point of a spear, hence the name. |
| Squid (YW2) | 13 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | Drying this squid will make it even more deliciously chewy. |
| Starfish (YW2) | 3 | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | These guys can regrow lost limbs. It almost seems like magic! |
| Stingray (YW2) | 24 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | This lovable fish is a huge draw at any aquarium...and it knows it! |
| Sweetfish (YW2) | 47 | It's most likely somewhere by a stream in Downtown Springdale. | A river fish known for its sweet meat. Good with salt! |
| Tuna (YW2) | 71 | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | This powerful fish barrels around like a scaly torpedo with gills. |
| Turtle (YW2) | 4 | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Uptown Springdale. | A cute turtle. Is walking slow the reason they live so long? |
