| Difficulty to find | Acquired by | Buy | Sell | Rare sell | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amberjack (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Anglerfish (YW1) | Can be fished rarely during the night at Rolling Waves Park Beach after acquiring the Fishing Rod in Chapter 5. | - | 21.00 | 42.00 | |
| Anglerfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Barracuda (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| Beakfish (YW1) | Can be fished rarely during the day at Rolling Waves Park Beach after acquiring the Fishing Rod in Chapter 5. | - | 13.80 | 27.60 | |
| Beakfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Beltfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| Black Bass (YW1) | A lake fish. Can be fished after acquiring the Fishing Rod in Chapter 5. | - | 1.95 | 3.90 | |
| Black Bass (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a pond in Mount Wildwood. | ||||
| Blackfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Carp (YW1) | A river fish. Can be fished after acquiring the Fishing Rod in Chapter 5. | - | 0.60 | 1.20 | |
| Carp (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a river in Harrisville. | ||||
| Catfish (YW1) | Found in rivers and lakes. Can be fished after acquiring the Fishing Rod in Chapter 5. | - | 1.50 | 3.00 | |
| Catfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a pond in Mount Wildwood. | ||||
| Cherry Salmon (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Uptown Springdale. | ||||
| Chub Mackerel (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Conger Eel (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Cowfish (YW1) | Can be fished during the day at Rolling Waves Park Beach after acquiring the Fishing Rod in Chapter 5. Can also be bought. | - | 9.90 | 19.80 | |
| Crab (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a river in Harrisville. | ||||
| Crayfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Mount Wildwood. | ||||
| Cuttlefish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Eel (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Shopper's Row. | ||||
| Filefish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Firefly Squid (YW1) | Can be fished at night at Rolling Waves Park Beach after acquiring the Fishing Rod in Chapter 5. | - | 2.16 | 4.32 | |
| Firefly Squid (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Flounder (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Flying Fish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Giant Huchen | A lake fish. Can be fished rarely after acquiring the Fishing Rod in Chapter 5. | - | 10.50 | 21.00 | |
| Giant Huchen (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Uptown Springdale. | ||||
| Grunt (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Halibut (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Jellyfish (YW1) | Can be fished at night at Rolling Waves Park Beach after acquiring the Fishing Rod in Chapter 5. | - | 2.40 | 4.80 | |
| Jellyfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| Koi (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in Gourd Pond in Breezy Hills. | ||||
| Loach (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a pond in Mount Wildwood. | ||||
| Lobster (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Mackerel (YW1) | Purchased from The Fish Place Can be fished during the day at Rolling Waves Park Beach after acquiring the Fishing Rod in Chapter 5. | 2.50 | 0.75 | 1.50 | |
| Mackerel (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| Marlin (YW1) | Can be fished rarely during the day at Rolling Waves Park Beach after acquiring the Fishing Rod in Chapter 5. | - | 30.00 | 60.00 | |
| Marlin (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Mullet (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Octopus (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| Porcupine Fish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| Porgy (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| Red Snapper (YW1) | Purchased from The Fish Place Can be fished during the day at Rolling Waves Park Beach after acquiring the Fishing Rod in Chapter 5. | 28.00 | 8.40 | 16.80 | |
| Red Snapper (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Reef Squid (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Rockfish (YW1) | Can be fished during the day at Rolling Waves Park Beach after acquiring the Fishing Rod in Chapter 5. Purchased from The Fish Place | 4.00 | 1.20 | 2.40 | |
| Rockfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Salmon (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Uptown Springdale. | ||||
| Sardine (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| Sea Bass (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Sea Horse (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| Shrimp (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| Snakehead (YW1) | A river fish. Can be fished rarely after acquiring the Fishing Rod in Chapter 5. | - | 4.80 | 9.60 | |
| Snakehead (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Blossom Heights. | ||||
| Softshell Turtle (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Mount Wildwood. | ||||
| Spear Squid (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Squid (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Starfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| Stingray (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Sweetfish (YW1) | Purchased from The Fish Place A river fish. Can be fished after acquiring the Fishing Rod in Chapter 5. | 13.00 | 3.90 | 7.80 | |
| Sweetfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by a stream in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| Tuna (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| Turtle (YW1) | A lake turtle Can only be found on Mt. Wildwood. Can be fished after acquiring the Fishing Rod in Chapter 5. | - | 0.90 | 1.80 | |
| Turtle (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Uptown Springdale. | ||||
| Whiting (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Amberjack (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Anglerfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Barracuda (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Beakfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Beltfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Black Bass (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a pond in Mount Wildwood. | ||||
| ★Blackfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Carp (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a river in Harrisville. | ||||
| ★Catfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a pond in Mount Wildwood. | ||||
| ★Cherry Salmon (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Uptown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Chub Mackerel (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Conger Eel (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Crab (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a river in Harrisville. | ||||
| ★Crayfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Mount Wildwood. | ||||
| ★Cuttlefish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Eel (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Shopper's Row. | ||||
| ★Filefish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Firefly Squid (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Flounder (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Flying Fish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Giant Huchen (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Uptown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Grunt (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Halibut (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Jellyfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Koi (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in Gourd Pond in Breezy Hills. | ||||
| ★Loach (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a pond in Mount Wildwood. | ||||
| ★Lobster (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Mackerel (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Marlin (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Mullet (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Octopus (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Porcupine Fish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Porgy (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Red Snapper (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Reef Squid (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Rockfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Salmon (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Uptown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Sardine (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Sea Bass (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Sea Horse (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Shrimp (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Snakehead (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Blossom Heights. | ||||
| ★Softshell Turtle (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Mount Wildwood. | ||||
| ★Spear Squid (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Squid (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Starfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Stingray (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Sweetfish (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by a stream in Downtown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Tuna (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in the sea in San Fantastico. | ||||
| ★Turtle (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere in a stream in Uptown Springdale. | ||||
| ★Whiting (YW2) | It's most likely somewhere by the seaside in Downtown Springdale. |